The political fallout from the end of Justin Trudeau’s era as prime minister continues to reverberate, as former finance minister and deputy prime minister Chrystia Freeland offers her perspective on the final, dramatic days of their governing partnership. In her book, Unreliable Boyfriend, Freeland details the breakdown of her working relationship with Trudeau, revealing how an unexpected push to remove her from the finance portfolio triggered a chain reaction that ultimately reshaped the nation's leadership.
According to Freeland, the rift reached a breaking point during a video conference in late 2024, when Trudeau informed her that he intended to replace her as finance minister. The conversation took place just days before she was scheduled to deliver the government’s fall economic statement. Rather than accept the reassignment, Freeland abruptly resigned on the very day the economic report was slated to be tabled in Parliament. Within weeks, Trudeau himself stepped down, clearing the way for Mark Carney to assume the Liberal leadership and lead the party through a high-stakes election cycle.
A Strategic Exit or Self-Preservation?
Reflecting on the turbulent exit, Freeland argues that her departure provided a necessary turning point for the government and Trudeau himself. She recalled a conversation with former Liberal prime minister Jean Chrétien following the cabinet blow-up, noting that Chrétien viewed the outcome as a blessing in disguise.
"Prime minister Chrétien said … in resigning, it was ultimately a better outcome for Canada, for the Liberal Party — and also ultimately for prime minister Trudeau because it allowed him not to lead our party to defeat. I think that is a very wise observation."
Before Trudeau's resignation, public opinion polls showed the Conservative opposition holding a massive lead, driven largely by voter frustration over economic stagnation and the rising cost of living. While Freeland insists that her book is fundamentally about her own vision and career rather than a personal expose on Trudeau, her account highlights how deep the internal fractures had become before the government unravelled.
Defending the Economic Record
Throughout her tenure, which began with the Liberal election victory in 2015 and included serving as finance minister from mid-2020 until her late-2024 exit, Freeland was one of the government's most prominent public faces. When asked whether she bears responsibility for the economic anxieties that damaged the administration’s standing, she stood firmly behind her record.
"I am very glad that as finance minister, I got us through COVID and I preserved our AAA credit rating while doing that. We were able to return to a sustainable fiscal path. Now, that was politically hard to do, but it was absolutely the right thing to do."
Despite her defense, public reaction to her comments has been mixed, with critics viewing her recent accounting as an attempt to rewrite her role in a difficult governing era.
"She was front and center for many of these terrible decisions and was the deputy prime minister through it all."
Others take a pragmatic view of the political machinery at play, arguing that high-level departures and strategic rebrands are standard protocol when a government faces near-certain defeat at the ballot box.
"I mean… sounds like a pretty typical career politician to me. They almost always put party over country, and they are incentivized to be that way because their remaining in their seat depends very much on their party’s appeal to their local constituents who put them there."
The Path Forward
While Freeland maintains that history will ultimately view Trudeau’s tenure in a positive light, she acknowledged that an earlier transition might have served everyone better. As Mark Carney charts a new direction for the government amidst ongoing international trade tensions and shifting geopolitical alliances, the retrospective accounts from Trudeau's former inner circle underscore just how narrowly the party navigated its transition power.